DSL vs. Cable-Introduction To The Two Major High-Speed Broadband Connection Providers
DSL vs. Cable – the never-ending battle between those two major high-speed Internet providers seems to interest you too, doesn’t it dear reader? Well look no further because you found a solution for your pain. The article you’re reading and this whole website is solely dedicated on information regarding the race DSL vs. cable. So are DSL modems better? Or should you choose cable modems over digital subscriber line modems? The answer is here! Read on and you will find information on both of those high-speed Internet connection types that will help you to compare them.
When comparing DSL and Cable modem internet we must have a look at some raw data which will help us understand how those technologies work and which one will suit our needs the best. We will start the article with some things you need to know about digital subscriber line broadband connection and then will continue with the same about high-speed cable Internet access.
DSL vs. Cable – High-Speed DSL Broadband Internet Essential Information
DSL vs. Cable – DSL Meaning:
We are able to receive DSL Internet by using the telephone network. The original meaning of DSL was Digital subscriber Loop however, as it got used more and more for Internet access we invented a new name for it which is digital subscriber line in the average Joe’s vocabulary or asymmetric digital subscriber line or ADSL.
DSL vs. Cable-Naked Digital Subscriber Line Connection:
If you don’t have PSTN or analog telephony service you can still use DSL broadband Internet connection. This is one of the best futures of this type of connection because you do not need to be subscriber to a certain home telephone service. One of the many names of this type of service is dry loop DSL or UNE which stands for unbundled network element. A really interesting fact is that after introducing the naked DSL the number of telephone land lines in the United States of America dropped to 172 million just over the course of five years!
DSL vs. Cable-DSL Download and Upload Speeds:
One of the many things will compare between DSL and cable Internet access are down one speed and upload speeds. However, before we do that there is some upfront information that I have to share with you about digital subscriber line speeds.
The rate with which you download files really depends largely on your Internet provider. However, most of the time an acceptable DSL data transfer in your direction would be between 256 kB per second and 40 MBit per second.
The data you transfer upstream through your Internet provider is another story – usually with an ADSL connection you would upload files much slower then you download them.
DSL vs. cable-DSL distance Importance
While using DSL broadband connection you should really take into account the distance between you and your Internet provider. It is estimated that distances over 1.25 miles will have a significant impact on your data transfer and you will have to less bandwidth available on your wires.
DSL vs. Cable-DSL setup:
The digital subscriber line set up is usually automatic but there are few steps that it has to always go to:
1. The transceiver goes through a self check
2. There is a connection check performed again by the transceiver and it ensures there is a connection between the computer and the DSL transceiver.
3. Your DSL transceiver synchronizes your computer and your data with the DSLAM.
Of course the process is much more complicated but this is just a short version of what really happens behind the scenes.
DSL vs. Cable-DSL Essential Equipment:
When subscribing to DSL Internet service provider you will also get a DSL modem. The modem is used to decode data used by computers and turn it into a suitable frequency range which can easily be transferred through a phone line.
However, as there are different types of digital subscriber line services you might get some additional functions such as a firewall provided by your DSL administrator. This is most common for ADSL broadband Internet connection.
DSL vs. Cable – High-Speed Cable Broadband Internet Essential Information
DSL vs. Cable – Cable Internet Origin:
Cable Internet access a.k.a. cable Internet is the type of broadband high-speed Internet service in telecommunications. This service is really similar to digital subscriber line or if FTTP [fiber to the premises]. However, in this case this Internet service uses cable television infrastructure which is far more different than the DSL that uses a telephone network to transfer data.
Both of the above-mentioned services are one of the most popular ways to access the Internet all over the world. However, they are competing with some newcomers such as wireless and mobile networks.
DSL vs. Cable – Cable Internet Access Download And Upload Rates:
One of the most important aspect of cable Internet is its download and upload speed. The rate at which data can be transferred to the user ranges out to 400Mbit per second. This is far more superior to the DSL Internet connection which is only 40 Mb per second. Another factor we should keep in mind of course is the upstream or the upload ratio which can range up to 20Mbit per second and can be as low as 384 kb per second.
As networks get bigger and bigger they have to upgrade their systems to CMTS which stands for cable modem termination system and allows them them to have more downstream and upstream ports.
Some cable Internet access providers use DOCSIS [data over cable service interface specification] which allows them to restrict the upload and download rates of a user.
DSL vs. Cable – Cable Internet Bandwidth Limitations:
One down side of high-speed broadband cable Internet access is the fact that users have shared bandwidth. Most services use statistical multiplexing to share the bandwidth between all their users equally. However this is not always effective and sometimes there are peak hours which lead to restriction of Internet access for some neighborhoods.
DSL vs. Cable – High Speed Cable Internet Service Types
Just like DSL high-speed broadband connection the cable Internet access I’ll so allows multiple plants for their users. You can either subscribe for cable Internet or a standalone cable Internet. Although you should keep in mind that was standalone Internet access you will have higher rates.
DSL vs. Cable – Cable Internet Modem:
The cable Internet modem is the bridge between you and your Internet service provider a.k.a. ISP and it uses radiofrequency channel infrastructure of a HFC or RFoG. Cable modems can also be used by the Internet service provider to deliver VoIP access. Voice over Internet protocol gives the ability to its users to not use plain old telephone services or POTC.
The only problem with voice over the Internet is that you have to subscribe to an online service such as Skype which brings the problem of having the need to turn on your computer if you want to use your telephone. This is one of these disadvantages of this type of service over DSL broadband connection.
However if you’re really keen on using voice over the Internet function of cable Internet access you can use a service such as Vonage which connects directly to your cable modem.
DSL vs. Cable Modem Comparison – Speed
DSL vs. Cable Speed Comparison:
DSL vs. cable speed comparison – now we’re in business! After he has the necessary tools to understand DSL and cable modem broadband Internet connection we can start comparing them. We will go to a few important points you considers and one of the most important one of those is the speed of your connection.
DSL vs. Cable Modem Speed Comparison In Theory:
DSL and cable speeds are not equal in theary. Theoretically speaking cable Internet access should have asked huge advantage over DSL. While the average DSL connection speeds can go up to 10 Mbit per second the top cable connection speeds is 40 Mbit per second or greater. There are certain types of digital subscriber line Internet services which can go up to 30 Mb per second (VDSL), however, most of the Internet service providers use ADSL or SDSL which are lower quality.
DSL vs. Cable Modem Speed In Reality:
Before making any conclusions though should know that in reality there is no much difference between DSL and cable speed. The reason for that is the simple fact of the Internet being a really complex thing and the speed numbers your Internet service provider gives you are really working in an ideal scenario. However,for the cable modem speed to reach about 40 MB per second you need to have no other people using the same network which is usually not the case. Many ISP providers limit your download and upload speeds so you cannot use the maximum amounts you’re capable of.
DSL vs Cable Modem Speed Limitations
When comparing DSL vs. cable speed one of the most important factor is the limits your Internet service provider has put over his network. Many network administrators use a cap for their customer’s Internet speed. This is often seen with cable ISP’s. While in theory you are able to get up to 40 Mb per second download rates in reality they might put a Of three or 4 MB per second to your computer.
There might be several reasons for that and one of them is that the DSL and Cable modem high speed internet provider wants to give a fair share for every user in his network. Another reason for that is that many Internet service providers believe that their users actually do not need so much Internet speed and this is usually true. Many cable Internet providers limit their speed in order to be able to have more users.
DSL vs. Cable Speed Comparison – Cable Speed:
DSL vs. Cable Speed Comparison – Cable Internet Download And Upload Rates
Cable Internet speed is one of the most important reasons why people prefer cable Internet access. Many people believe that once they install cable Internet they will be able to have download speeds of up to working megabytes but usually that is not the case. In reality most people have between five and 10 MB of download speed and 500 to 800 kB of upload speed.
There are many reasons for that and some of them are following:
DSL vs. Cable Speed Comparison – Cable Speed Uncertainty Reasons
Cable Internet speed hugely depends on how big your neighborhood is and the user base of your Internet service.Bandwidth of the cable Internet is shared locally.
Another really important factor to consider is age of your computer as older computers tend to have lower speed witch cable internet independently of the limitations their ISP has put.
If your cable modem or router is not configured properly you might experience lower download and upload speed.
DSL vs. Cable Speed Comparison – DSL Speed:
If you look at the history of the Internet you will clearly see that if we compared DSL vs. cable speed back in the days cable Internet would have a tremendous advantage. However as many Internet service providers update their network infrastructures we tend to see a equality between their speeds. There are two important factors you should consider when looking at digital subscription line service speed.
DSL vs Cable Speed Comparison – DSL Download And Upload Rates
The first thing is the download speed that your ISP promises you. Usually to be between three and 10 MB. This is the speed with which you can download files from the web, PSP sharing sites and others.
The other thing that is really important for comparing DSL vs. cable speed is the upload rate. Most of the time it will be between 100 and 700 kB per second.
As you can see the download speed is much higher than the upload speed and this is with a certain type of digital subscription line service called ADSL.
Many business owners choose to use SDSL which gives them equality between their upload and download rate.
DSL vs Cable Speed Comparison – DSL Speed Uncertainty Factors:
You can never be certain of how much download and upload speeds you will attain a given moment with DSL Internet connection. The reason for that are as follows:
If you have better wiring for your phone line you will get higher speeds.
If you have a bigger distance than 1.2 miles with your ISP you will eventually get speed loss. When comparing DSL vs. cable modem Internet you will have to take into account the fact that digital subscription line Internet is distance dependent.
Viruses on your computer. If you have malware in your computer it will eventually rob your Internet speed regardless of how much your Internet service provider allows.
All older computers will usually get lower speed with DSL Internet connection as well as Cable Internet connection.
Resources:
